In a world where sustainability has become increasingly important, pet parents are now seeking ways to reduce their environmental pawprint while still providing their curious companions with engaging, high-quality toys. This comprehensive guide explores the world of sustainable pet toys and eco-friendly pet products that don't sacrifice style or function.

Why choose sustainable pet toys? 

The pet industry produces significant waste, with millions of pounds of plastic ending up in landfills each year. Let's face it—your cat couldn't care less about the molecular composition of their toys (they prefer the Amazon box to that $30 robotic mouse anyway), and your dog isn't checking labels for sustainability certifications.

By opting for sustainable pet products, you're not only reducing environmental impact but often providing safer, more durable options for your canine or feline who, ironically, would be just as happy with a stick from the backyard or an empty paper towel roll.

PS - We believe that most pet parents are doing their absolute best with the resources they have, and there's no judgment here for those who can't prioritize eco-friendly options during challenging economic times. Being informed about sustainable pet products simply means you'll have that knowledge in your back pocket for when opportunities arise, whether that's replacing a worn-out toy, celebrating a special occasion, or when your financial situation allows for more choices.

Benefits of eco-friendly pet toys:

• Reduced environmental impact: Less plastic waste and carbon "paw"print

• Non-toxic materials: Often safer for pets to chew and play with than synthetic or plastic materials

• Durability: Often last longer than conventional alternatives

• Aesthetic appeal: Many sustainable options are beautifully designed

• Support for ethical businesses: Companies committed to environmental responsibility

What makes a pet toy sustainable?

When searching for the best sustainable pet toys, consider these key factors:

Materials

The foundation of any eco-friendly pet toy starts with its materials. Look for: 

• Natural fibers: Hemp, organic cotton, wool, and jute 

• Recycled materials: Fabrics, rubber, or plastic from post-consumer waste 

• Renewable resources: Bamboo, cork, or sustainably harvested wood 

• Biodegradable components: Materials that will break down naturally when disposed of 

Manufacturing process

Truly sustainable toys consider the entire production cycle: 

• Low-waste manufacturing: Minimal excess materials and efficient production 

• Non-toxic dyes and adhesives: Plant-based or water-based options 

• Ethical labor practices: Fair wages and safe working conditions 

• Reduced carbon footprint: Local production or carbon-offset shipping 

Packaging

Don't forget to consider how the toy is packaged: 

• Minimal packaging: Reduced or eliminated unnecessary wrapping 

• Recyclable materials: Paper, cardboard, or easily recyclable plastics 

• Plastic-free options: Companies committed to plastic free dog toys often extend this philosophy to their packaging 

Best sustainable pet toys by category

For dogs 

Chew toys 

Durable chew toys are essential for many dogs, and sustainable options include: 

• Natural rubber toys: Made from rubber tree sap rather than synthetic materials

• Olive wood chews: Naturally durable and appealing to dogs who love to gnaw (supervise closely particularly with puppies who could swallow small bits)

• Hemp rope toys: Biodegradable alternatives to synthetic rope toys

• Coconut fiber chews: Sustainable and naturally antimicrobial

Interactive toys 

Keep your dog mentally stimulated with these eco-friendly options: 

• Puzzle toys made from recycled plastics: Challenging and environmentally responsible 

• Treat dispensers crafted from bamboo or wood: Sustainable materials that stand up to play 

• Snuffle mats made from upcycled fabrics: Engage natural foraging behaviors 

• DIY toys: An empty egg carton + some treats or a folded, treat-filled towel can provide hours of fun with no additional waste 

Fetch toys 

For active play sessions, consider: 

• Wool balls: Natural, biodegradable, and often available in beautiful colors 

• Cotton canvas frisbees: Washable and durable alternatives to plastic discs 

• Reclaimed rubber balls: Made from recycled materials while maintaining bounce 

For cats 

Interactive Toys 

Engage your cat's hunting instincts with: 

• Organic catnip toys: Stuffed with organic catnip in natural fabric pouches 

• Wool felt toys: Biodegradable and available in creative designs 

• Sisal toys: Natural fiber that cats love to claw and chase 

Comfort toys 

For cats who enjoy cuddles: 

• Organic cotton stuffed toys: Non-toxic and washable 

• Recycled fabric kickers: Perfect for bunny-kicking and made from repurposed materials 

Enrichment toys 

Mental stimulation is important for cats too: 

• Cardboard puzzle toys: Recyclable and replaceable 

• Natural fiber wand toys: Sustainable alternatives to plastic wands 

• Bamboo treat puzzles: Renewable resource that stands up to play 

Stylish and sustainable 

Today's stylish pet toys for dogs and cats prove that sustainability doesn't mean sacrificing aesthetics. Many eco-friendly toys feature modern design elements like clean lines and contemporary shapes. Since eco-friendly pet toys often use plant-based dyes, many of these products come in natural color palettes and beautiful earth tones. And artisan craftmanship is often a hallmark of toys that are better for the planet, boasting hand-crafted details and unique variations.

For pet parents who value both design and sustainability, aesthetic dog toys and aesthetic cat toys from eco-conscious brands offer the perfect blend of responsibility and style. 

Innovative approaches to sustainable pet play 

The pet industry is seeing some creative innovation in sustainable materials and designs. Some brands are turning entirely to products produced via ocean plastic reclamation, crafting toys made from plastic recovered from oceans or recycled from plastic bottles.

Others are getting creative with upcycled waste, turning materials like worn denim and cardboard into brand new offerings for pets. These innovations demonstrate how sustainability can drive creative new approaches to pet enrichment.

Making the switch to sustainable pet products 

Transitioning to a more eco-friendly pet lifestyle doesn't have to happen overnight. Consider these approaches: 

• Replace as needed: As old toys wear out, replace them with sustainable alternatives 

• Start with basics: Focus first on the toys your pet uses most frequently 

• Research brands: Look for companies with transparent sustainability practices 

• Consider durability: Sometimes investing in better-quality, longer-lasting toys reduces waste 

The importance of non-toxic materials 

Beyond environmental concerns, many pet parents are increasingly concerned about chemical exposure. While there aren’t a ton of pet-focused studies on the dangers of various materials, many vets agree with minimizing exposure. Non-toxic dog toys and non-toxic cat toys avoid: 

• BPA and phthalates: Common in many plastic toys

• Lead and heavy metals: Sometimes found in paints and dyes

• Formaldehyde: Used in some manufacturing processes

• Chemical flame retardants: Often unnecessary and potentially harmful to pets

By choosing natural materials, you may be helping your pet to avoid these exposures. When in doubt, always double check with your vet.

Our top recommendations 

Looking to make the sustainable switch? Here are our a few of our top picks for sustainable pet toys currently on the market:

For Dogs: 

The West Paw Toppl

Not only is the Toppl a must-have for pets with a high-need for mental stimulation, this enrichment toy is made in the USA with zero-waste and “infinitely” recyclable Zogoflex® material. It’s safe and non-toxic, with absolutely no BPA, Latex, Phthalates, or Silicone. But what really stands out is West Paw's Join the Loop program, where pet parents can mail back any used West Paw Zogoflex or Seaflex toy and they will recyle it into a brand new one!

Shop it here.

The Kind Pet Stingray Cat Toy

This adorable cat toy is made sustainably with hemp canvas and stuffed with organic cotton and buckwheat hulls to provide a naturally fun crinkle texture. With materials sourced from the USA, cats will love hunting their newest seaworthy prey and you’ll feel better adding it to your cart. Better yet, the Kind Pet claims that several of their toys can be composted if cut into small pieces.

Shop it here.

Outward Hound Planet Dog Snoop Treat Dispensing Toy

Durable and made in the USA, this puzzle toy is made out of BPA, lead, and phthalate-free Orbee-Tuff TPE material. Infused with mint oil to keep your pup's breath clean as they pounce and play, the durability means that you shouldn’t have to replace it frequently (as long as your pup isn’t a super-chewer!)

Shop it here.

BetterBone

BetterBone provides maximum durability for aggressive chewers using natural, non-toxic ingredients (cellulose and vegetable oil) as a safer alternative to nylon chews and antlers. The hypoallergenic, GMO-free chew toy comes in three densities (SOFT, MEDIUM, and HARD) to match any dog's chewing style while supporting sustainability and pet health.

Shop it here.

P.L.A.Y Tuna Baguette Kicker Cat Toy

Hungry? This toy combines luxurious fabrics with USDA-certified organic catnip to create an irresistible playtime experience for your cat. Its eco-friendly features include PlanetFill® filler made from 100% recycled plastic bottles, AZO-free dyes, and stringent safety standards. Hours of fun for your cat, sustainable, hand-made craftsmanship for you.

Shop it here.

A greener future for pet play 

Choosing sustainable pet toys is a small but meaningful step toward reducing your environmental impact while providing safe, engaging play options for your furry family members. As consumer demand continues to drive innovation in this space, we can expect even more creative and eco-friendly options to become available. 

Remember that the most sustainable toy is often one that lasts - so regardless of material, choosing durable, high-quality items that suit your pet's play style will always be the most environmentally friendly option.

Lizz Caputo is the Manager of Content Strategy at Figo, animal enthusiast, and owner of a rescued senior American Bully. Her hobbies include checking out new restaurants in her area, boxing, and petting dogs of all shapes and sizes.